The claim: HIPAA prevents anyone from asking if you are vaccinated
As mask-wearing and social distancing guidelines relax for fully vaccinated individuals, businesses are navigating how to implement new policies in their stores. Many businesses are ending mask requirements only for fully vaccinated customers.
Vaccine opponents, including Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, R-Ga., are using the occasion to resurrect the false claim that the HIPAA federal privacy law protects individuals from being asked about their vaccination status.
On May 18 several GOP members refused to wear masks on the House floor in defiance of House rules on mask-wearing, including Greene. When asked if she was vaccinated, Greene told reporters that asking about her vaccine status was a HIPAA violation.
Greene is not the only one spreading this false claim, which has spread widely on social media in recent days.
“The rule is simple, HIPAA protects EVERY American from disclosing ANY of their health records to ANYONE,” claims an image posted on Instagram May 13.
The poster clarified she was referring to vaccine and mask requirements in her caption.
“If anyone asks for your vax status, tell them they have no right to know,” she wrote. “This is authoritarianism by the way. Literally communistic.”
Fact check: CDC’s new guidance for fully vaccinated people is not ‘out of the blue’
Other examples of social media posts with the claim can be seen on Instagram and Facebook.
The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act, or HIPAA, is a law that prevents health care professionals from sharing private health information without the patient’s permission.
But experts agree the interpretation of HIPAA cited by Greene and others online is completely inaccurate. The law has no bearing on who can ask or answer questions about health status outside of a health care setting.
USA TODAY contacted several accounts that posted the claim.
Experts say HIPAA does not cover vaccination questions
USA TODAY debunked a similar version of this claim last summer when mask opponents encouraged others to claim HIPAA allowed them to avoid mask mandates.
Alan Meisel, a professor of law and bioethics at the University of Pittsburgh, told USA TODAY at the time that HIPAA’s rules only apply to sharing information between “covered entities.” The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services describes covered entities as “health plans, health care clearinghouses, and those health care providers that conduct certain health care transactions electronically.”
(Photo: Getty Images)
Meisel said the claim that HIPAA protected individuals from being asked about their vaccine status is “utter nonsense.”
Fact check: COVID-19 vaccines won’t make the common cold or flu ‘extremely lethal’
“It in no way prohibits business owners and other individuals from asking people if they have been vaccinated,” he wrote in an email to USA TODAY. “In fact, it doesn’t even prohibit healthcare entities mentioned above from asking people if they have been vaccinated.”
Georgetown University Law Professor Lawrence Gostin agreed, saying, “Non-health care businesses are not subject to HIPAA.”
While businesses and individuals maintain the right to ask others for vaccination status, that does not mean anyone has to provide that information.
According to Gostin, when a business asks an employee or customer for their vaccination status, that “individual then has a choice whether to provide proof of vaccination. If the person does not, then he or she can be excluded from entering the premises.”
Fact check: COVID-19 vaccines don’t cause magnetic reactions or contain tracking devices
In short, HIPAA doesn’t have any effect outside a health care setting.
Our rating: False
We rate the claim that HIPAA prohibits businesses and individuals from asking for others’ vaccination status FALSE, because it is not supported by our research. Experts agree HIPAA only applies to health care entities sharing information. Health care entities can ask individuals for their vaccination status. Businesses can ask patrons and employees whether or not they have been vaccinated. And individuals can then choose whether they want to answer or forego that service.
Our fact-check sources:
- USA TODAY, May 13, New CDC guidelines say vaccinated Americans can now ditch the masks, with a few exceptions: Live COVID-19 updates
- USA TODAY, May 18, Mask wars: As stores update COVID-19 policies for vaccinated customers, are more conflicts on the horizon?
- USA TODAY, May 18, Group of House GOP lawmakers removes masks in chamber on Tuesday
- Nicholas Wu, May 18, tweet
- HHS.gov, accessed April 19, Summary of the HIPAA Privacy Rule
- USA TODAY, July 19, //2020,// Fact check: No mask? You can ask why — it isn’t against HIPAA or the Fourth or Fifth Amendments
- HHS.gov, accessed April 19, The HIPAA Privacy Rule
- Alan Meisel, May 19, email exchange with USA TODAY
- Lawrence O. Gostin, May 19, email exchange with USA TODAY
Thank you for supporting our journalism. You can subscribe to our print edition, ad-free app or electronic newspaper replica here.
Our fact check work is supported in part by a grant from Facebook.
Source: Read Full Article