- A high-quality casserole dish can handle the heat of the oven without being damaged, has large handles for easy maneuverability, and cooks meals evenly without burning.
- The Arcuisine Glass Rectangular Roaster Pan is our top pick because it's made of durable borosilicate glass, bakes excellent casseroles, and comes with a five-year warranty.
- See more: The best stockpots
If you like roasted vegetables, enchiladas, baked macaroni and cheese, lasagna, or casseroles of any variety, a good baking dish is an indispensable part of your cookware collection. Also referred to as casserole dishes and roasting pans, baking dishes come in a broad array of shapes, sizes, and materials.
For the purposes of this guide, we are going to focus on rectangular dishes that are roughly the standard 13 by 9 inches (give or take an inch or two). We are also only going to cover glass and ceramic models since they have slow heat distribution, which is best for cooking popular casserole ingredients, like pasta, cheese, and eggs.
The baking dishes included in our guide are easy to clean, designed to last, and they produce excellently baked, roasted, and sometimes broiled foods.
Here are the best casserole dishes:
- The best overall: Arcuisine Glass Rectangular Roaster Pan
- The best high-end casserole dish: Revol Belle Cuisine Rectangular Roasting Dish
- The best on a budget: Pyrex Easy Grab Oblong Glass Bakeware Dish
- The best for lasagna: Emile Henry 11 x 8-inch Lasagna Baker
Prices and links are current as of 9/3/20. We reformatted this guide and added a product showcase so you can easily shop all our picks at once.
The best casserole dish overall
If you're looking for a simple glass baking dish that is resistant to thermal shock, the Arcuisine Glass Rectangular Roaster Pan is your best bet.
What sets the Arcuisine Glass Rectangular Roaster Pan apart from the other casserole dishes in our guide is that it's made in France of borosilicate glass. This glass is tempered and features boron, which helps with its heat, scratch, and stain resistance. Heat resistance is important for even cooking and ensuring the glass doesn't crack when you set your hot casserole on a cold counter.
It's important to note that the sizes include the handle measurements. For instance, the 13.75 by 8.65- inch pan is closer to 12.5 by 8.25 inches. This bakeware is dishwasher safe and is backed by a five-year manufacturer's guarantee.
Pyrex has switched to soda-lime glass, which is more susceptible to shattering, which is why we're recommending a less common French import. Because it's an import, you may notice that while the dish itself is cheap, the shipping is quite pricey. We've factored the shipping cost into the price below.
There aren't any complaints of this casserole dish shattering. The biggest negative complaint is that it's somewhat hard to clean around the logo, which is molded on the interior.
Pros: Made of durable borosilicate glass, 5-year manufacturer's guarantee
Cons: Small handles, not broiler safe, measurements in the description are misleading
The best high-end casserole dish
Spending a little bit extra on a larger baking dish like the Revol Belle Cuisine Rectangular Roasting Dish is well-worth your money thanks to its easy-to-grab handles and durable construction.
Like the other two baking dishes we've covered so far, the Revol Belle Cuisine Rectangular Roasting Dish is made in France. In fact, founded in 1789, Revol is one of the most prestigious porcelain makers in France.
The dish is slip cast, so the handles are cast in one piece with the dish. The smooth white enamel finish is nonporous, nonreactive, and resistant to thermal shock, chipping, and staining. Plus, it cleans up easily. The dish is dishwasher, microwave, freezer, and oven safe up to 572 degrees Fahrenheit.
If you're regularly bringing entire casseroles to serve at the table, you'll appreciate the elegant look of the Revol dish. It's quite a bit more appealing to the eye than a typical clear glass baking dish.
Pros: Large handles, easy to clean, resistant to chipping
The best on a budget
For an affordable glass baking dish that's easy to use and clean, we recommend the Pyrex Easy Grab Oblong Glass Bakeware Dish.
The Pyrex Easy Grab Oblong Glass Bakeware Dish is the only casserole dish in our guide made of tempered soda-lime glass, which is manufactured to reduce the chance of thermal shock but isn't as durable as borosilicate glass. But it's still great at resisting odors, staining, and warping — and the price is right.
The Pyrex baking dish is safe for the dishwasher, freezer, fridge, microwave, and oven up to about 450 degrees Fahrenheit. The Easy Grab Dish is made in the United States and comes with a two-year warranty.
This is my favorite of the four baking dishes I own. The handles are a definite benefit when removing items from the oven, and they don't take up too much storage space. The dish also fits effortlessly in our dishwasher. However, I generally wash it by hand since the dishwasher tends not to get the job done. Lastly, the actual measurements of the dish are 11.75 by 7.5 inches at the bottom and 13 by 9 inches at the top with a depth of about 2 inches.
Back in 2015, Pyrex seemed to have a quality control issue the lead to some of these dishes shattering upon removal from the oven. But, looking at reviews from just the past 12 months, it appears Pyrex has solved this issue.
Pros: Inexpensive, large handles, lightweight
Cons: Older reports of the dish breaking into countless pieces, misleading measurements
The best casserole dish for lasagna
The Emile Henry 11 x 8-inch Lasagna Baker has steep sides, making it great for layered dishes like lasagna or hearty casseroles.
What sets the Emile Henry Lasagna Dish apart from other baking dishes is its steep sides and broiler-safe materials, which makes it ideal for lasagna. First of all, you can layer your lasagna uniformly from bottom to top. Then, as the baking cycle comes to an end, remove your foil cover, and broil for browned perfection on top.
Crafted in the Burgundy region of France, this dish is made of high-fired ceramic that allows for even browning without burning or sticking. The stoneware's glossy, translucent glaze protects it from showing utensil marks, crackling, or discoloration. Emile Henry backs this casserole dish with a three-year warranty.
The handles are a bit small, but it's still relatively easy to transport as long as you're not going long distances with it.
Pros: Broiler safe, steep sides, easy to clean
Cons: Small handles
A note on thermal shock
The downside of glass and ceramic is that they are both susceptible to thermal shock. Thermal shock occurs when parts of a dish expand or contract at different rates when coming in contact with a hot or cold surface. This difference in expansion can lead to shattering. Glass is more susceptible to thermal shock than porcelain and other ceramics.
There are steps you can take to avoid thermal shock. Never put an empty dish in a heated oven. Also, if you have a meal frozen in a baking dish, let it sit on your counter for a while before popping it in the oven. It may also be helpful to place your baking dish on a towel once you take it out of the oven rather than putting it directly on a cold counter.
Check out our other kitchen gear guides
The best meat thermometer
If perfection is your goal, then a meat thermometer should be an indispensable tool in your kitchen repertoire. These are our top picks for the best meat thermometers.
The best stock pots
A top-quality stockpot will last for the rest of your life and serve as the perfect tool for whipping up stocks, stews, chili, and even home canning projects. These are the best stock pots.
The best cast iron skillet
Cast iron skillets heat evenly, are naturally non-stick, and will last you a lifetime if properly taken care of. Equally at home over an open campfire or on the stovetop of a Michelin-star restaurant, it's one of the most versatile pieces of cookware you can own. These are the best cast-iron skillets.
The best cookware sets
Whether you consider cooking a hobby or a chore, there are several types of cookware to choose from to suit your needs. Many different cookware sets made from various materials are available, including stainless steel, nonstick aluminum, cast iron, and copper. These are the best cookware sets.
Subscribe to our newsletter.
You can purchase syndication rights to this story here.
Disclosure: This post is brought to you by the Insider Reviews team. We highlight products and services you might find interesting. If you buy them, we get a small share of the revenue from the sale from our commerce partners. We frequently receive products free of charge from manufacturers to test. This does not drive our decision as to whether or not a product is featured or recommended. We operate independently from our advertising sales team. We welcome your feedback. Email us at [email protected]
Source: Read Full Article